In our last blog piece, we asked whether we should perhaps be opening our minds to more extreme scenarios, because the recent pace of change has outstripped the expectations of many of us. We still find this persuasive. But in the spirit of alternative scenarios, we turn that question on its head and ask: can “extreme scenarios” get us into trouble? In the second of our two-part series, we address that important question.
There certainly is no shortage of extreme scenarios being aggressively advanced today:
“AI will bring nirvana.”
“You’re dead wrong. AI will destroy human life on earth.”
“I don’t care. I will be the one human they keep around to entertain them.”
“Democracy is incompatible with liberty, so democracy must be destroyed and replaced with me ruling the world so we can all go to Mars and populate the galaxy with 10 to the 58th power humans, each of whose future lives is morally as valuable as yours or mine, so I must make as much money as possible now by any means necessary so as to use it to maximize the future prospects of humanity in space, and also, I must propagate my superior genes as far and wide as possible to make humans just like me who see things the way I do… oops, I just blew half a billion dollars on losing political candidates.”
Facile forecasts and Jenga towers
This last, rather parodic entry combines the politics of Peter Thiel, the Effective Altruism of William MacAskill and its “maximize current earnings now to save humanity later” acolytes, and the future vision of Elon Musk, to demonstrate the tunnel vision that seems inherent in much current “futurism.”
Effective Altruism and “Muskism” (the title of a recent book) build Jenga towers of single-point forecasts out to 100 million years hence, held together by a rickety series of assumptions piled up to a dizzying height, each assumption lowering the probability of the entire vision coming true by some indeterminate percentage, thus rendering the odds of it coming true to be near zero.
Now, do serious business planners actually use such black-and-white extreme scenarios to plan for their businesses? Almost certainly not, outside of Santa Clara and San Mateo Counties. However, such extreme scenarios do have a knock-on effect on the broader business world, because right now tech leaders (especially the perceived leaders in AI) represent the largest companies in what is seen as the fastest-growing and most influential sector of the economy today.
The ultimate effect of these heaven-hell extreme scenarios on “regular” business planners can be paralyzing – and foreshortening. When “geniuses” who have garnered unprecedented and growing wealth and power say we may all be slaves of some robot in the near-to-mid-term, it’s hard for intelligent (but more normal) people to completely dismiss the suspicion that they might be onto something.
How extreme scenarios can narrow strategic thinking
Is the world going to be destroyed by AI? Good – we don’t need to waste time planning for that future. Is the world going to be nirvana thanks to AI? Same. So it seems pointless to plan too far ahead. Better to simply play out one’s current budget spreadsheet, plus or minus 5% a year, for five years or so, and wait for the tsunami.
This is an unserious, strategically brittle way of “planning.” It cannot possibly come to grips with the fundamental uncertainty of human events, nor is it a sober way to allocate resources against the full range of plausible eventualities. It’s essentially just a way to gain attention in an increasingly breathlessly attention-driven world.
As a recent New York Times Magazine article points out, the millennial or dystopian visions of Silicon Valley narrow our focus rather than broaden it. It’s tunnel vision to the nth degree – Jenga towers piling questionable assumption upon interlocking assumption. All other possibilities are simply ruled out. You have to put all your chips on one AI genius or another – or they or their acolytes might call you stupid.
The case for messy, human-scale scenarios
Serious planning for the future has to prepare for messy, non-extreme, non-unipolar worlds, not for utopia/dystopia point-forecast caricatures. Scenario planning is the best way to do that. If you’re going to build these Jenga towers of assumptions, don’t stop with one – or two, or three. Spread out your extreme scenarios – and ask yourself how the “nirvana” scenario might actually be very bad, and the “dystopia” scenario might have its advantages.
Often some of our competitors’ scenarios – and some of our own first-draft attempts – come out too pat. “This is the best-case case scenario, this is the bad scenario, this is the medium scenario, this is the weird scenario.” We find that really fleshing out our scenarios, with even “extraneous,” messy details, as long as the whole remains internally consistent, leads to deeper and more profound client insight into the future. Ask yourself, have you ever seen a pristine “best case” operating environment – ever? Messiness and ambiguities are essential elements of good, realistic planning scenarios.
We need to plan for provocative, but grounded, futures in which actual humans still have to live and to deploy scarce resources in order to achieve their ends, in a world that is neither autocratically controlled by robots, nor in which the robots provide our every need.
But should we also plan for worlds in which robots threaten us, or are of great use to humanity? Absolutely. Plausible future challenges cannot be simply ignored, and the pace of change is truly unprecedented. Huge changes seem quite likely within the next decade.
But the very detailed, extremist visions of Silicon Valley gurus are of little use to serious planners. Even if we think they are all geniuses… they disagree with each other. Which genius to believe?
Beware the Jenga towers, people.